My concern about adolescent girls in contemporary US culture led
me to read several popular texts that influenced my thinking in
regards to how to appropriately situate today's girls and understand
the challenges that many face. These texts inform my thinking so
profoundly that I must present them here to properly credit the
basis of my viewpoint and research on this subject (See Brumberg,
1997, Wolf, 1987, Pipher, 1995 and Ornstein, 1994).
As it is believed by some experts today (Brumberg, 1997), girls
are sexualized in the media and in their day-to-day lives at a much
earlier age than in the past. The real risk to personal safety is
far greater and the self-hatred of their own bodies is manifested
in more extreme ways at this time than ever before in history. Well-intended
parents in the United States must work against culture in their
efforts to rear strong, well-adjusted girls. Many parents cannot
make enough time to help their daughters forge the difficult terrain
of becoming women. Many parents are harried and focused on earning
a living; they are subject to the same cultural pressures faced
by their daughters. Our consumer culture is bombarding us with many
messages, some messages demand that we work harder and faster, spend
and acquire more things, buy leisure time and happiness. America's
"junk culture" might be an annoyance or merely a diversion
for us as adults, but for girls trying to find their way, looking
for people and ideas with which to identify, it can be a disaster.
The American Association of University's Women's report, Shortchanging
Girls, Shortchanging America (1991), asserts that for many girls
the passage into adolescence is not just marked by menarche or a
few new curves. It is marked by a loss of confidence in herself
and her abilities. It is marked by a scathingly critical attitude
toward her body and a blossoming sense of personal inadequacy. According
to the survey, middle school is the beginning of the transition
from girlhood to womanhood and this is the time of the greatest
self-esteem loss.
Girls with healthy self-esteem have an appropriate sense of their
potential, their competence, and their innate value as individuals.
They feel a sense of entitlement: license to take up space in the
world, a right to be heard and to express the full spectrum of human
emotions. We live in a culture that is ambivalent toward female
achievement, proficiency, independence, and right to a full and
equal life. Our culture devalues both women and the qualities that
culture itself projects onto us, such as nurturance, cooperation,
and intuition. Our culture has taught us to undervalue our contributions
and ourselves (Orenstein, 1994).
According to Brumberg (1997) for the most part the media depict
life for girls as perilous and females as powerless. Much of the
time, women are presented as sex objects and every year the women
get younger and look more like pre-adolescent girls. Advertisers
are hawking merchandise to women and girls that give them the message
that they are not "all right" the way that they are. If
girls and women buy the advertised product, they will smell better,
be less hairy, be sexier, that they will be closer to the "airbrushed
ideal" we are to believe men desire.
It is not wise for us to ignore corporate America's exploitation
of women and girls, corporations that use female bodies to advertise
all types of goods and services. This objectification of female
sensuality is a strong message that girls receive that can render
them powerless. Girls and women are manipulated into believing that
their primary worth is to "be beautiful." It is implied
that to achieve this narrow definition of beauty a girl must consume
many beauty products. Then she can use her beauty to manipulate
men and get what she wants. The media feed this myth to corroborate
the messages sent by advertisers who drive our consumer culture
and to maintain the power structure as it is. There is no emphasis
placed on the beauty of women as powerful, intelligent, spiritual,
sexual creatures whose beauty and "light" comes from within.
That message does not sell products and challenges the dominant
hegemony perpetrated throughout the media.
One of the primary messages communicated to girls from television,
movies, advertising, video games, popular music and many of their
elders is to work hard to be a man's desire; this is presented as
a fundamental objective for a girl. Contemporary girls are
in trouble because there is a disconnection between how girls mature
and how they are treated in our culture. Young women are developing
earlier, but are not nurtured in a healthy, respectful way. Instead
of supporting and honoring our girls, or offering them a stable,
affirming reflection by which they could view themselves, the media
and the capitalist marketplace exacerbates self-consciousness and
precocious sexuality (Brumberg, 1997).
Perhaps surprisingly, it is argued that in some ways feminism has
actually made things more difficult for girls (Pipher, 1995 ). Girls
might be more oppressed in some ways than they used to be. They
are coming of age in a more dangerous, sexualized and media-saturated
culture. They face incredible pressures to be beautiful and sophisticated,
which in middle school means experimenting with alcohol and drugs
and being pressured to exhibit overt sexuality. The world contemporary
girls navigate is less protected. Pipher feels that America is a
girl-poisoning culture. Television, popular music, films and sexist
advertising all send a similar unhealthy message to girls in our
society and abroad. Our culture limits some girls' development,
diminishes their wholeness and leaves some of them traumatized.
Some assert that girls' development, beginning in middle school,
provides them with many challenges that move them into womanhood
(Wolf, 1987). These challenges are primarily focused on demonstrating
their willingness to participate in sex acts and obtaining many
material possessions. Our girls move toward womanhood through the
demarcations of what they can buy and own or who wants to sleep
with them. The danger to girls is that the culture often makes them
turn into women in ways they do not choose before they are psychologically
ready, and determines their maturity as a passive biological readiness.
It gives them little opportunity to work toward becoming women.
Becoming a woman is not seen as healthy goal toward which to struggle
and to claim at last with pride.
Our culture on the whole does not support the important process
of girls individuating into adult females. Nor does it support women
choosing to be sexual when and how it is appropriate for them. In
our world, "Prove that you are woman," means simply "Take
off your clothes" (Wolf, 1987). Adolescent girls need to be
encouraged to be independent and autonomous while they are still
being provided with a safe place to live and grow. Clearly, girls
need a safe and sacred respite while they are tested and challenged
to explore themselves. They need to be given adequate trials to
encourage them to develop their physical, spiritual and emotional
selves for the realities of adult responsibility. Providing a safe
haven and appropriate benchmarks for girls to prove themselves has
become increasingly more difficult to do for even the most diligent
and loving parents or guardians.
The media and music videos, specifically, are pop culture vehicles
that often objectify and undermine the uniqueness, inner beauty
and strength of girls and women. As a culture, we should be telling
girls what they already know, but rarely see affirmed: that the
lives they lead inside their own bodies, the skills they attain
through their own hard work and the unique phase in their lives
during which they may explore boys and their own erotic nature,
are magical. This period of their lives, as young adolescents, begins
a life cycle of sexuality that should be held sacred (Wolf, 1987)
|